A missing body. A dead body. A somebody. A nobody.

It’s New Year’s Eve in Southern California, and Shae Wilmont, the adored celebrity host of IShop—a popular shopping site—is eager to reclaim her life. Her stalker’s been caught. But en route to a party, a bizarre encounter lands her in the wrong place at the wrong time. 

Only one person knows where she ends up. It’s where no one can find her. 

Shae’s stunned fans quickly galvanize to track her down. Yet the charismatic Shae they know, who delivers digital intimacy to viewers who’ll buy anything she sells, off camera is an enigma—private and strangely insecure—unable to let anyone get close. When startling personal secrets are exposed during the investigation, the paradox of Shae begins to unravel.

The lives of three strangers collide In this dark psychological thriller. Honey, a hardworking waitress at the local diner, is a trouble magnet. Her flair for making bad decisions—mostly to protect others—has ignited a ticking time bomb. Creepy Lawrence, a Detective Bureau fast-tracker with a fetish for latex gloves and a perverse obsession with Shae, becomes fixated on solving this high-profile missing person’s case. And Shae, with millions of fake friends but hardly a real one. All three are hiding something, but only two of them are lying.
Time is running out. But the only way to find Shae, is for someone to discover who she really is.

Nothing is what it seems in this propulsive locked-room thriller—a story about the need for belonging and the destruction caused by secrets. This page-turner bares our assumptions of strangers. Who we believe without judgment and who we judge without believing.

Natiello is back with another gripping suspense, keeping you guessing until the final page.


Available in paperback and ebook!

Buy Now From Your Favorite Bookstore.


For Book Clubs

Thank you so much for choosing FOLLOWING YOU for your book club.

Reader's Guide

Find a list of questions for your book club discussion here.

Send me a pic!

Send me a pic of your book club group so I can feature it on my site.

Invite Me!

If you’d like me to attend your book club discussion via Skype or Facetime, contact me.